Scordato Bakery Inc

About Scordato Bakery Inc

Scordato Bakery Inc, located at 5011 W Howard Ave in Milwaukee, WI, is a beloved local gem known for its irresistible baked goods and warm, authentic Italian charm. Stepping into this bakery feels like entering a family kitchen-one where generations of culinary tradition are preserved with pride and passion.

The highlight here is undeniably the cookies. Whether you're a fan of buttery pecan fingers, rich turtle cookies, or festive holiday assortments, every bite delivers nostalgic, handmade goodness. These treats are especially sought-after around the holidays, drawing loyal customers who don’t mind the lines, knowing the reward is well worth it. The Christmas cookies in particular are a major hit, often flying off the shelves, so coming early is a smart move.

Another favorite at Scordato Bakery is the Sicilian pizza. When available, it's a must-try-thick, hearty, and full of bold, satisfying flavors that reflect true Italian roots. And for those who stop in during lunch hours, there's more to discover. The bakery also serves a selection of savory items, including generously portioned sandwiches and hearty pasta dishes like lasagna, made with care in the kitchen by the owner’s family.

Visitors appreciate the personal touches-the owner is frequently on hand, ready to assist, and the staff works efficiently, even during the busiest rushes. There’s a clear sense of community here, with many customers going out of their way to make this bakery a regular stop, even if they live far outside Milwaukee.

Scordato Bakery isn’t just a place to pick up cookies-it’s a place that invites you to experience the heart of Italian-American baking, where quality, hospitality, and tradition come together under one roof. Whether you're craving a sweet treat or a warm, comforting meal, this bakery promises a memorable and satisfying visit.